
or is it?
"Writing is like prostitution. First you do it for love, and then for a few close friends, and then for money."
Moliere
I had a friend once, who told me that she was going to write the next great american novel. She fancied herself to be the next Hemingway. She had just pursued a graduate degree at Harvard for a field unrelated to writing. When she discovered that she actually hated her chosen field of study, she decided that she would be a writer instead. Yet the one thing lacking was, she actually didn't love writing either. It ended up being merely an excuse to stall the less than glamorous task of seeking employment. So she took a year off and wrote things she refused to share with the rest of the world. Hemingway remained safe from her threat of competition. She never did write any novel, much less THE great american novel.
Can one just decide to be the next Hemingway?
There are some who believe the answer is yes. All it takes is a good agent or advertising. You too can become famous if you merely market yourself well. Well I don't believe it. There is a huge fundamental difference between being a good writer and being a salesman. Maybe I am naive. Maybe I am clinging onto the romantic notion that a good writer has something of worth to say regardless of how good of a marketing strategy they employ. The writing itself is the essential piece, not the desire for fame or fortune.
I dare say that Hemingway did not set out to be Hemingway. Most writers and artists do not know their future. There are a great number of creators of art or literature who were not popular in their time. They wrote or painted for the passion of it. Van Gogh is a prominent example of this. Considered to be a flop in his time, he had no inkling of the immense popularity of his works after his death. Van Gogh didn't paint for fortune or fame. He painted because he had raw passion and a fierce desire to do so.
Again, I am most likely holding dear to a romantic ideal of writing which is not the norm nowadays and especially with our technological advances which enables all of us to claim to be "writers" and "artists."
I am currently reading a book entitled, "The Cult of the Amateur: How today's internet is killing our future" by Andrew Keen. It is an excellent commentary about how far we are going as a society to demolish any standards of excellence in the arts. Writing is but one example. In today's world, anyone can be an "expert" at virtually anything. Joe Schmo down the street who who holds no degrees, reads no books, and lives in his mother's basement, can suddenly be an expert of anything from raising orchids to writing about global warming. Wikipedia is one site which makes us all experts of anything we choose. Despite the lack of credibility, thousands of people still flock to the site for a daily dose of misinformation.
Take a look at television for yet another example of how the public is constantly bombarded with the facade of the expert. The ads for the cholesterol lowering drug, Lipitor, come immediately to mind with the ad campaign featuring a Dr. Jarvik to promote the product. The truth of the matter finally came out that although he has a medical degree, Dr. Jarvik is not a cardiologist and is not licensed to practice medicine. The ad was subsequently taken off the air when this little fact was discovered.
I fear for the art of writing as well. There are millions of blogs out there and the number is steadily growing. It seems everybody and their grandmother writes a blog. As Andrew Keen points out: "If we keep up this pace, there will be over five hundred million blogs by 2010, collectively corrupting and confusing popular opinion about everything from politics, to commerce, to arts and culture. Blogs have become so dizzyingly infinite that they've undermined our sense of what is true and what is false, what is real and what is imaginary." It seems hypocritical of me to quote this as I am writing this for my blog. Yet you just try to be a writer without a blog nowadays. Blogs have become a permanent part of the writing world for good or for bad. I personally love blogging. It is a way to reach people who you would have never had an opportunity to form a connection with before. Yet as much as I do love this platform for writing, I am all the more keenly aware of the dangers and pitfalls as well.
One only has to peruse the blogosphere for some minutes to find that most of it is dreadful schlock. The term of "writer" has been so blasphemed that it holds no meaning anymore. Andrew Keen foretells of T.H. Huxley's "Infinite Monkey Theorem" to be coming true: "Huxley's theory says that if you provide infinite monkeys with infinite typewriters, some monkey somewhere will eventually create a masterpiece-a play by Shakespeare, a Platonic dialogue, or an economic treatise by Adam Smith." And today's technology has provided the monkey's with web 2.0 capabilities. Imagine the lasting effects of such a universe of low to zero standards for truth or quality. We are already there.
We have become a nation of a People magazine mentality.
Where are the good writers or journalists? How can one even find them amongst all the varied and assorted rubbish which litters the internet? What has happened to passion and a love for the art of writing? Are we to all be drowned out by the biggest mouths, the most successful schmoozers, and successful marketers of carefully crafted narcissism? Does anyone care anymore about any sort of quality control? Do we truly enjoy being herded like cattle to the next blog, the next website, touted as being "popular" by the number of hits or mindless comments to some self serving glutton?
I was reminded of how bad things are becoming when I saw a blogger recently who was actually bribing people for comments with the offer of a prize of a gift card. Is this what "writing" has evolved into? Forget about hard work or passion. It isn't about the writing at all don't you know? It is about all the hundreds of "friends" you can acquire on myspace or the number of times people link to you. Who needs good writing? Talent and hard work is secondary to obtaining a large enough mirror for people to repeat how wonderful you are. It isn't how well you write that matters it is who you know and how well you can play the game.
I am greatly disheartened by this state of affairs. In order to keep doing what I love to do I must put horse blinders on and shut out most of the world. In my quiet place I will write with reverence and a simple heart. Writing has and always will be my first love. No matter if the monkeys soon control the world, I will hold onto my pen and paper for dear life. I will write. It is who I am and what I do regardless and despite the lack of money or fame or anything else.
I am a writer.
And so I write...
8 comments:
Wow, I really liked this post alot! I myself am not a writer at all. I love my lil blog because it allows me to express things to strangers that I would never do in person. I can read your passion, and that is a really great thing! I try to keep my posts personal. I was asked recently if my post's were real occurences. My reply was " how could I make up some of this stuff?" Thanks for putting on your blinders! Can't wait for your next one!
You are a writer. One of my life aspirations was to get a link on your blog. It seems that you have only linked really worthwhile reading here.
I too am a writer but like all writers, I sometimes write crap. I used to say that we must write often because 90% of our work would be craptacular and only about 5-10% would contain the jewels worth sharing. So I blog and the stuff that is decent, I save for my memoir. I appreciate the encouragment and sometimes mere tolerance of my readers and I am always trying to fine-tune my craft.
excellent, but for one thing: NO degree is required to write well, only thing you truly need is constant practice and perseverance, honing and refining each piece you write, whether long hand or on your qwerty keyboard
and 'rejection' slips are no barometer of the quality of what you write, poetry or prose....
thanks for reading and for coming to see me. oh my goodness miss denver...i love visiting your blog. you are refreshingly honest and always ready to explore. you are right...i am selective about my links and that is why you are on my list!
and good to see you coby..that one post of yours just blew me away. i am glad i found your gem of a blog.
Brava! Brava! Love this post!
Funny I got this in my email box today, no kidding...
"You are truly a gifted reporter and writer. By turning the JEC hearing into a narrative, you made it a fascinating read. I looked at your profile in the hope that you were from Florida.
I’m editor (and sole staff member) of a non-profit news service I founded last year after 30 years in health reporting for newspapers. I’m looking for someone who can write as well as you for a new consumer page I’m starting. But so far no luck.
Do you happen to know anyone in Florida who is one of those affected by the price-gouging on these drugs? If so please put me in touch, and thanks,"
My first thought was "am I a reporter?" Well, I guess if I tell others about stuff that goes on, I sorta am. "am I a writer?" Well, since I have been putting thoughts into words, I suppose so.
Then, "turning the JEC hearing into a narrative" My thought - what's a narrative again? is that like the recitative in an opera where the soloist gets to tell a whole lot of story in a short period of time?
In high school, I studied the five-paragraph essay under the pretense of learning the "art of BS". Very true, this skill served me well in college. But knowing HOW to write; I just do what I do. I don't analyze it.
I guess that makes me an untrained writer. But darn it. If I lived in Florida, I guess I could continue to vent about drug prices, attend meetings or keep up on news, and write about it on an actual "news" site. Oh well, I'm not moving. But I'll keep writing.
Hmmm...you "write" well about writing! It speaks volumes...
Linda D. in Seattle
Merelyme,
You are right to keep writing, you do it so well.
When I started my blog, I wrote for me. Then people started commenting and one thing led to another and slowly I began writing for my readers. It was a slow insidious progression but soon it became tedious and un-me. It's easy to get caught up in that.
Now I've gone back to writing for me. Sometimes I put those missives on my blog. The blog has become a way for me to communicate with family and friends and to serve as a journal for memoir writing if I ever get to that.
rel
Merelyme,
This is a loaded post and I have been pondering it all day.
First of all, thank you so very very much for adding my humble blog to your blogroll. You were the second person to do so, and I appreciate it.
As for writing, wow, Hemingway. Van Gogh, Yes. I understand...it's close to my heart.
It's sad when some of the best bloggers out there have worked in newsrooms and have degrees in journalism and have lost careers due to downsizing and the internet.
My own job in a newsroom was outsourced to India.....
I can tell you myself, when I was 19 and took my first creative writing course in college, I started what I thought was the Great American Novel.
I finished it when I was 22. I was lucky. I had a NYT published writer take me under his wing and introduced me to his literary agent. She loved my book, but told me it was too "Literary": and there was no market for a book that would sell under 5,000 copies.
I remember going home on the bus from Manhattan crying so hard I sniffled and had black mascara running down my cheeks.
In a fit of rage later that night, I burnt it, vowing from that point on, never to write for other people again.
Over the years I have written 2 other novels, shown to no one.
I've did well as an entertainment writer and blogger, but that is empty words about the next Flavor of the Month.
I;ve found a lot of blogs I love and have added to my RSS feeds (like yours), and am amazed at the talent out there. I don't know, maybe 100 years ago, we would have all been published writers with books and gotten the satisfaction of seeing your own name on a book's spine.
But about writers, I think some are born writers, some have writing thrust apon them.
I don't know which one I am, but I know if I couldn't write I would stop breathing and die.
Post a Comment